July 22nd, 2008
Boys will be boys/butterflies
We are sort of mellow about gender roles. There’s that wonderful Woody Guthrie song that goes
Why can’t a grandpa be a grandma? Tell me why oh why?
Same reason your daddy is not your mama
Goodbye goodbye goodbye
That’s about as deep as it gets around here. The boys know that boys have different anatomy and ladies are generally the only ones who can have babies, but other than that we haven’t really ever clarified what boys are supposed to do or like or want or be. It helps too that our kids aren’t in school right now and we have no television and generally insulate ourselves from the outside world, partly because we’re antisocial jerks (me) and partly because we’re just lame (Kevin).
So it’s turned out to be sort of an interesting social experiment. In the absence of any overt pressure to be “all boy”, what does a boy act like?
Observations/results so far:
You end up with a boy who is a dancing swan showing off his ballet moves one minute, and blowing things up the next. Nicolaus loves things that are glittery and jewel-encrusted, has already picked out some lovely sandals at Target that he hopes I’ll buy him for summer, and plays with babies and animals and really can’t decide which is prettier: unicorns or peguseses.
But then he’ll spend an entire day playing this thing where see? There’s two brothers. And one of their parents was an Indian and the other was a white settler, and so one of the brothers is Indian and one is a white settler and so together! They fight evildoers on both sides! Holy shit, you guys. What they do to the bad people they capture? The Lone Ranger would not approve.
For starters, they shrink the bad guy down to the size of a plastic toy generic gi joe-type guy. It’s their only army man toy, and it has no arms because of an inexplicable design choice where the guy is supposed to have interchangeable arms. What the fuck? My mother in law bought it, and even she does not know why. It came with all these little parts and several arms, which are all now missing. So all we have is an armless dude. Which was perfect though because it turns out that Nicolaus has a magical RING, which looks suspiciously like something that a pre-teen girl might buy at Claire’s, that REMOVES YOUR ARMS. The arm removal takes place after the ring shrinks you down so you can’t beat anybody up. It’s all very intense.
Sometimes he wears gigantic butterfly wings out in public. When people whisper “Hee hee look at the butterfly,” he is wholly offended. A butterfly! Do I look like a sissy?? And he defiantly declares, “I am not a butterfly. I am a FAIRY.”
He’s king of the fairies in fact, on account of this crown and also thanks to being several hundred times larger than most fairies.
Which was excellent when we went to the playground with my nephew last week. The butterfly wings caused much confusion because, like many people do, all the kids wrongly thought he was a butterfly. So my nephew took up the cause, and marched around telling everyone, “My cousin is a GIANT FAIRY.”
And Nicolaus nodded and was very pleased. I’m writing this down because whether both of them turn out gay or straight or what, that’s going to be awesome to tell him about when he’s older.
But his favorite book at the library is The History of Weapons. It’s a picture book that shows in great detail all of the weapons from ancient Greece and India and China and so on and the best way to get him to be good at the post office is to bring that book and a bunch of strips of paper and tell him to sit down and mark all his favorite pages. He’ll tell you which knives are for cutting and which are for stabbing and which are for… well, anyway. Boy stuff.
The experiment continues with Graham. His favorite color is bright magenta, also known as pink. He steals my flowery headbands and wears them. And as much as he loves cars and robots and building and wrecking, the other day my mom took him to the Walmart toy section to buy him a dump truck, and instead he came home with a baby doll wearing a lavendar hat with little hearts. It moves and coos and says Mama. He named her Campy Ard, and he and Nicolaus have been taking excellent care of her. Admittedly, they care for her between periods of neglect that would warrant a call to CPS, but it’s not because they’re boys. It’s because they’re little kids. That’s why everyone’s against 5 and 2 year olds having children. They make sweet but crappy parents.
Last night Nicolaus showed Graham how to change Campy’s diapers. Nicolaus adores babies, and is as sweet and attentive as any little girl would be.
But then again, last night I heard him say, “Graham, there’s something about her that’s not 100% baby. I think she might be mostly baby but a tiny part warrior. The next time people are attacking the city, we’ll have to report to the baby and find out what weapons she wants us to use.”
So there you go. You can take the overt societally-generated preconceived gender roles out of the boy, but you can’t take the boy out of the overt societally-generated preconceived gender roles.
July 22nd, 2008 at 10:23 am
My own 5yo was swanning around in fairy wings himself the other day. I asked him if he was a butterfly. He said “No, I’m a fairy - a boy fairy! And do you know what boy fairies eat? HUMAN FLESH!” Kinda cute, kinda creepy. I suspect a lot of little boys are like this, if they haven’t had the desire to run around in jewelry and wings shamed out of them. I love reading all the stories about your boys. Their personalities really shine through!
July 22nd, 2008 at 11:30 am
I only hope my son will be as sweet and imaginative as yours!! And I think its wonderful that you are just letting your kids be themselves, regardless of society’s ‘rules’ on gender. Did you perchance listen to Free to be You and Me as a kid?
July 22nd, 2008 at 2:03 pm
My 3yo’s best friends are boys. They love play dates at our house because Harper has oodles of princess dresses and accessories as well as fairy/butterfly wings. There is some very typical boy fighting over who gets to wear her wedding dress (from when she was a flower girl in a cousins weddings). My (gay) uncle calls thses play dates “Harper’s Cross Dressing Parties.” I think it’s a hoot– what kid doesn’t love dressing up as, well, anything?
July 22nd, 2008 at 2:03 pm
Oh my gosh! Sounds just like my son! He even calls all pink colors purple, so his favorite color is purple. He loves wearing fairy wings, and unicorns. And destroying everything. And the history of weapons. We have many toy boxes — one is called the weapon box. He never liked stuffed animals much, unless they were something weird, like a bug. But he still doesn’t carry them around like his sister does (she loves puppies and horses and babies and hearts and also likes stabbing people with swords.)
July 23rd, 2008 at 8:05 am
I clicked over to here from Julia’s Here There Be Hippogriffs, and oh. my.
I haven’t laughed so hard first thing in the morning in a very long time. Thank you so much. I adore the fact that you’re saving that tidbit from the playground, I wish my parents had held on to more things like that to share with me.
July 23rd, 2008 at 9:37 am
Well, let’s see, you have a giant fairy and a campy doll. Then there are weapons and mass destruction. I think you have it all covered from one end to the other. :-)
I think it’s marvelous that you don’t cramp your boys’ style with artificial gender roles. They are first, and foremost, human beings. Even Kinsey knew that male/female isn’t black and white, it’s a sliding scale.
July 23rd, 2008 at 12:31 pm
I was directed here by Jen of Volatile Gas World after she read my recent post about buying my son a doll. My partner and I were both laughing hard at the stories of your sons in this post. Thank you!
July 24th, 2008 at 11:37 am
I have a little boy who wants to a princess who builds castles and train layouts. I’m relieved to see I’m not the only parent letting them run with it: http://hhhouse.blogspot.com/2008/06/little-landscaping.html